I Drink No Wine That’s Past Its Prime

2001 Provenance Carneros Merlot

I figured that I had probably waited too long, but it wasn’t in my Cellartracker although I’d had the bottle for years. But I was in the mood for a Merlot because I wanted to try it with my seared duck breast dinner. I would usually open a Pinot, but was more in the mood for the depth of a Merlot on this cold winter night.

I was going to grab one of my Central Coast Merlots when I saw the bottle of 2001 Provenance Carneros Merlot resting on a shelf. When I saw the vintage, I was immediately a little worried because there’s nothing good that can out of a bottle that’s past its prime, right?

I opened the bottle and poured it into a glass. The color was beautiful – a beautiful deep red rimmed with garnet, which is just what you’d expect from a wine of this age. The nose was fragrant with earth, tobacco, chocolate, plums, and a touch of cedar.

And then I tasted it.

Dammit.

The earth elements were fully intact, complementing the wonderful nose. It wasn’t a bad drink, but its core is gone, the fruit only a distant echo. I had waited too long to drink it, and I was greeted by a mere wisp of its former self. I Merlot v Pinot3tried everything I could conjure up to bring it back; I decanted it, let it warm up a little, swirled it a lot, didn’t swirl it at all, etc. So I pronounced and went looking for another wine. I had to face the fact that this wine was past its prime.

I snagged a 2011 Seaglass Santa Barbara Pinot Noir that I had picked up at Cost Plus last weekend for $9.99 (on sale). In the glass, it was the color of a Rhodolite Garnet, Merlot v Pinot2with just enough translucency when held next to a light. It was very pretty in the glass.

I thought it was unusually light-bodied for a Santa Barbara Pinot as it felt more Oregonian in character, but then again, it was only ten bucks. It smelled like Pinot – raspberries, cherry coke, a touch of smoke and strawberries. It had a solid bracing acidity that cut through the fat of the duck breasts, so there was no complaint there. A nice wine – a Double Gold Medal winner in the 2013 San Francisco Chronicle Wine Competition – I still found that while I really liked it, I didn’t love it. Maybe that’s because I was still pretty disappointed over the Provenance and still had the echo of the gentle, departed Merlot lingering on my palate.

Sigh.

 

 

Enhanced by Zemanta

About Vegas Wineaux

Hi! I'm the Vegas Wineaux and love to write about my experiences with wine, food, Wine Country, and Las Vegas! Click on one of the buttons under the Subscription form to follow me on Facebook, Twitter, and YouTube.

Post Your Thoughts